Idea 1
Turning Ferality into a Practice of Care
When a crisis shows up on your doorstep, what kind of person do you become? In Poets Square, Courtney Gustafson argues that care—sustained, imperfect, daily care—is both a survival strategy and a radical reorientation to a world that routinely abandons people and animals. She contends that tending to a sprawling colony of feral cats outside her Tucson rental forces her to confront the limits of individual goodness, the failures of public systems, and the hard math of scarcity, while also revealing unexpected reservoirs of community, creativity, and hope.
Across this memoir, you see how the line between wild and feral isn’t just biological—it’s moral and political. Wild animals evolved away from us; feral animals are the ones our systems created and then cast off. In that gap, Gustafson finds a mirror: to care for feral cats is to stare down abandonment as a design feature of modern life. The book follows her from the first sleepless nights listening to paws on the roof to a years-long immersion in rescue work, neighbor relations, social media virality, and the economics that determine whether living beings get to eat, heal, and stay warm.
What the book argues
Gustafson argues that choosing care inside broken systems changes you at a cellular level. It softens you where you’ve been guarded (her attachment to a sickly orange cat named Goldie), toughens you where you’d rather not look (euthanizing cats hit by cars), and links your fate to others—human and animal—whether you wanted that or not. She suggests that the difference between “I don’t want them to suffer” and “I don’t want to see them suffer” becomes a moral pivot; once the suffering moves to your front step, you either reorganize your life around response or you look away.
How the story unfolds
Early chapters map the clumsy beginnings: naming cats as a way to notice (BeeBee, Reverse Monkey, Mr. Business), rationing Walmart paté, and learning what TNR (trap-neuter-return) really means when thirty cats are multiplying in real time. From there, the book braids four threads: a personal reckoning with scarcity and grief; a ground-level education in community organizing through colonies like the “Trash Pals” at Desert Palms; a gendered critique of who does rescue work and how they’re treated; and the uneasy windfall of social media virality that unexpectedly pays the bills (and saves her house).
Why it matters
If you’ve ever wondered why some people seem to have endless capacity for care, Poets Square shows the hidden machinery: repetition, ritual, and an honest accounting of loss. It matters because the cats keep standing in for something bigger—precisely where safety nets fail. Gustafson’s day job at a regional food bank becomes a prism: the same scarcity math that makes people guard granola bars (“resource guarding,” as her therapist notes) is what makes Monkey the calico hiss and swipe over a bowl. Stability changes behavior—of humans and cats alike (a theme echoed in behavioral economics; see Mullainathan & Shafir’s Scarcity).
What you’ll learn in this summary
You’ll meet unforgettable animals—Goldie, the flat-as-a-pancake napper who hates eating; Monkey, the bully starved into meanness who becomes goofy once fed; and Sad Boy & Lola, a bonded rooftop pair who model a kind of protective love Gustafson didn’t know was possible. You’ll see how gender and class play out in alleys and parking lots (“men call cats sluts”), why empathy is a more durable organizing tactic than punishment (Richard, the Trash Pals caretaker; Francisco, the Hotdog Man), and how viral videos can both save a life and complicate your ethics.
We’ll also sit with grief that doesn’t tidy itself into meaning (the death of Dr. Big Butt), the body-image fallout of stepping off the stage of the male gaze (“letting myself go” in order to crawl under cars), and the radical ordinariness of making a home where animals and humans can rest. Along the way, we’ll compare Gustafson’s ideas to conversations in feminist care ethics (Eva Feder Kittay), grassroots mutual aid (adrienne maree brown), attachment science (Amir Levine’s Attached), and the creator economy (Kevin Kelly’s “1,000 True Fans”).
Key idea
Care doesn’t fix broken systems—but it does create a counter-system you can live inside: a carport turned sanctuary, a spreadsheet turned lifeline, a driveway turned commons. That work can change your outcomes (it literally buys her house), but more importantly, it changes your reflex: from looking away to staying with.
By the end, you don’t just understand how one woman managed thirty feral cats; you see a blueprint for how you might meet the next feral thing that crosses your threshold—inside your family, on your block, or in yourself—and choose to keep showing up.