Idea 1
Surviving Hate with Love and Art
What do you do when violence collapses the frame of reality you trusted? Knife is Salman Rushdie’s intimate, unsparing answer to that question. One year after a 24-year-old man rushed the stage at the Chautauqua Institution and stabbed him repeatedly in a 27-second attack, Rushdie makes a claim that is as old as tragedy and as modern as the feed: hate may savage the body, but only love and art can reassemble a life. He contends that survival is not an end state but a practice—of telling the story yourself, of relearning your own body, and of refusing to surrender the future to someone else’s narrative of you.
Rushdie structures this meditation in two arcs—the Angel of Death and the Angel of Life. The first follows those 27 seconds into the trauma bay at UPMC Hamot in Erie, the ventilator he describes as an “armadillo’s tail,” the ruined right eye destined never to see again, the left hand with severed tendons and nerves, the humiliations of the body, the nightmares of the mind, and the stubborn voice inside that whispered two syllables: “Live. Live.” The second arc brings you into the disciplined work of recovery: Rusk Rehabilitation at NYU Langone, the ruthless grace of his hand therapist Monica, the compassionate clarity of ophthalmologist Dr. Irina Belinsky, the slow re-entry into New York, the reaffirmation of a private love with his wife, the poet and novelist Rachel Eliza Griffiths (“Eliza”), and the decision to return to the Chautauqua stage—this time upright, in a new Ralph Lauren suit, and unafraid.
The Core Claim
Knife argues that violence is not only physical harm but an attempt to seize authorship of your story. Rushdie insists on repossession. He refuses to live inside the perpetrator’s narrative—religious rectitude, ideological grievance, and the flattening label of “victim”—and instead writes forward: a first-person recounting (unlike his third-person memoir Joseph Anton), an imagined interrogation of his assailant (“the A.”), and a forthright restatement of his lifelong defense of free expression. Along the way, he reframes miracles (he doesn’t believe in them, but admits his survival feels like one), locates meaning in disciplined care, and stakes happiness—not rage—as his final rebuttal.
What You’ll Learn
You’ll see in granular detail what violence does to reality (“the crisis of the real”) and to the body (intubation; chest drains; catheterizations; the eyelid sewn shut under inadequate anesthesia). You’ll sit with the lonely interior of a near-death experience (no tunnel of light, only the ache of dying far from Eliza and his children) and hear how strangers—an audience, a retired fireman named Mark or Matt Perez pressing a thumb to his neck—made survival possible. You’ll watch the rebuilding: the unglamorous rigors of rehab, Monica’s sea-monster tools working the scar of the open palm, the decision to keep the damaged eye rather than rush to prosthesis, the long crosshatch of outpatient visits, scares (an MRI that read “cancer likely” before resolving), and incremental wins (touching thumb to little finger, making a fist, reading galleys of Victory City aloud).
You’ll also learn how private love and family-wide solidarity countermand terror’s script. Rushdie threads the meet-cute that began on a PEN World Voices stage in 2017 (he literally knocked himself out on a glass door as Eliza walked ahead), their 2021 wedding in Wilmington (Zoomed to his London family), and the five years of “white ink on white pages” happiness that preceded the knife. Eliza’s actions—the emergency flight, the no-sleep bedside vigils, the production-level logistics of medevac, police escorts, and ambulette transfers—become as central as any surgeon’s. Together they decide to document everything on camera, asserting creative control in the face of annihilation.
Why This Matters Now
Knife lands in a moment of what Rushdie calls a “world war of stories”—competing mythologies weaponized by tyrants, sectarians, and social platforms. He has little patience for the right’s co-option of “freedom” or the left’s censorious fragility; his north star remains the First Amendment’s “tongue set free” (pace Elias Canetti). The book is also an argument about religion: keep faith private, he says, but when it is weaponized in public it becomes everybody’s business. He draws a bright line between the art that challenges orthodoxy and the orthodoxy that tries to kill art—and extends a long view of vindication (Ovid, Mandelstam, Lorca outlasting their oppressors).
A line to carry with you
“Terror must not terrorize us. Violence must not deter us.”
In the chapters ahead, you’ll follow the 27-second attack and its moral reverberations; the body’s repair, humiliations and all; the imaginative cross-examination of “the A.”; the case for speech over sanctimony; and the return to the site of harm to stand where he fell. If you’ve ever had your life blown open—by illness, grief, public humiliation, or literal violence—Knife reads like a field manual for how to take the pen back. It’s unabashedly literary (Beckett, Calvino, Saramago, Pirsig, Borges, Dylan, and E. E. Cummings all walk through these pages) but lands in the blunt American vernacular of the ER: live or die. Rushdie chooses life, and, crucially, he chooses how to tell it.